> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.altamiraequity.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# A One-Day Stay in Tier 2: Both Insurers Reverse Out as Workday Jumps In
- URL: https://www.altamiraequity.com/scorecard-tier2-reversal-2026-11-14/
- Published: 2026-11-16T21:43:01.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-16T21:43:01.000Z
- Description: Tier 2 shrank 25 to 24 in the 14 November edition: Allstate (70.5 to 69.4) and Chubb (70.0 to 69.5) reversed out a day after entering, Workday jumped 66.5 to 70.6 on its technical score alone, and VeriSign and Blackstone swung 8 to 10 points on flat prices.
- Author: Altamira Capital
- Tags: Research, #qc-review

Tier 2 shrinks from 25 names to 24 in the 14 November edition (prices of 13 November), Tier 1 stays empty, and breadth flipped positive — 252 scores rose, 232 fell and 31 were unchanged across the 515 names scored in both editions, a day after decliners led 291 to 177\. The scored universe grew to 516 with one addition (Vylor, in Tier 4). But the headline is at the tier line: both insurers that crossed into Tier 2 yesterday fell straight back out, the only entrant arrived on its chart alone, and the two largest score moves happened while prices barely moved.

## The exits: one day was all they got

![Total scores either side of the Tier 2 line, 13 to 14 November: Allstate 70.5 to 69.4, Chubb 70.0 to 69.5, EOG Resources 70.8 to 71.2 and Workday 66.5 to 70.6](https://www.altamiraequity.com/content/images/2026/11/scorecard-tier2-reversal-2026-11-14-line.png)

Total scores either side of the Tier 2 line, 13 to 14 November: Allstate 70.5 to 69.4, Chubb 70.0 to 69.5, EOG Resources 70.8 to 71.2 and Workday 66.5 to 70.6\. Source: External 516 KPI Scorecard dataset.

**The Allstate Corporation (ALL)** fell 70.5 to 69.4, one day after entering. The business case did not break — its fundamental composite rose 65.1 to 65.6 and its Value pillar is still a perfect 100.0 — but the tape faded (technical score 83.0 to 78.3) and the QC gate never endorsed the stay (NOT QUALIFIED, 10 of 13). **Chubb (CB)** fell 70.0 to 69.5, also one day after entering at exactly the line: its fundamental composite slipped 67.4 to 66.3 as the Growth pillar dropped 45.1 to 40.2, against a Value pillar still at 99.3 and a gate still at 9 of 13\. Value-led crossings at the line are rented, not owned. The third of yesterday's entrants held: **EOG Resources (EOG)** improved 70.8 to 71.2, still one criterion short of the gate at 12 of 13, still at a full price — fair value $150 against a price of $158.32, a margin of safety of about −5%.

## The entrance: a technical crossing

![The two halves of the score for the day's two movers: Allstate's fundamental composite rose 65.1 to 65.6 while its technical score fell 83.0 to 78.3; Workday's fundamental composite was flat (68.6 to 68.2) while its technical score leapt 61.6 to 76.3](https://www.altamiraequity.com/content/images/2026/11/scorecard-tier2-reversal-2026-11-14-halves.png)

The two halves of the score for the day's two movers: Allstate's fundamental composite rose 65.1 to 65.6 while its technical score fell 83.0 to 78.3; Workday's fundamental composite was flat (68.6 to 68.2) while its technical score leapt 61.6 to 76.3\. Source: External 516 KPI Scorecard dataset.

**Workday (WDAY)** jumped 66.5 to 70.6 — up 4.1 points, from rank 52 to rank 23 — almost entirely on the market's half of the score: the technical reading leapt 61.6 to 76.3 and the trend state flipped MIXED to UPTREND, while the fundamental composite was flat (68.6 to 68.2). The support underneath is real but narrow — a Shareholder Returns pillar of 100.0, a Value pillar of 93.3, and a fair value of $286.91 against a $196.45 price (a margin of safety of about +32%) — against a Quality pillar of just 35.9 and a QC gate passing only 7 of 13 (NOT QUALIFIED). Workday is the insurers' mirror image: they entered on value and left on tape; it entered on tape, and the gate has yet to agree.

## The day's extremes were spreadsheet moves

**VeriSign (VRSN)** posted the universe's largest fall, 62.7 to 54.5 — Tier 3 to Tier 4, rank 89 to 218 — at a price that did not move ($312.48 to $313.02). Its fundamental composite collapsed 58.9 to 47.4 because the dataset's five-year return-on-invested-capital input swung from +3,370% to −12,213%: with a negative equity base that ratio is arithmetic noise, but the scorecard prints it anyway, and the Quality pillar fell 77.3 to 42.3 with it.

**Blackstone (BX)** was the mirror image, the universe's largest rise, 47.0 to 56.9, on a price gain of just 1.4%. Its fundamental composite jumped 56.6 to 67.1 (Value pillar 61.9 to 91.7), its fair value was revised from $75.79 to $174.68, and its margin of safety flipped from about −56% to about +31%. It remains Tier 4 — technical score 33.1, DRIFTING — a model revision, not a market verdict. The same signature ran through utilities in smaller type: five names, Eversource among them, fell 3.4 to 5.9 points as their free-cash-flow-yield inputs reset to zero while prices edged higher.

## The top, and the queue behind the line

Arista Networks (ANET) held #1 at 77.3, down from 77.8: its fundamental composite improved to 73.1, its technical score cooled 91.0 to 87.1, and the pullback widened its margin of safety to about +14% (fair value $230 against a $197.29 price). The QUALIFIED count held at 13 universe-wide. Tier 3 grew 101 to 102 on a six-for-six swap, and trend states improved at the margin (UPTREND 134 to 141, DRIFTING 142 to 132).

Closest to the line sits yesterday's story, unresolved. **Deckers Outdoor (DECK)** rebounded 68.3 to 69.7 — three-tenths short of Tier 2 — holding the universe's second-highest fundamental composite, 87.3, behind only NVIDIA's 87.7, its technical score still DRIFTING at 28.5\. AppLovin sits a tenth ahead, at 69.8.

## What it means

Three lessons. A crossing carried by a single pillar — value for the insurers, technicals for Workday — lasts exactly as long as that pillar does. The blend can also move violently with no market input at all, as VeriSign and Blackstone showed in opposite directions: when a score swings 8 to 10 points on a flat price, the first question is which input changed. And the tier's most instructive pair is now Workday and Deckers, less than a point apart — one all tape over a modest business grade, the other an elite business grade waiting on its tape.

*Sources: External 516 KPI Scorecard, editions of 13 and 14 November 2026 (prices of 12 and 13 November), full 515- and 516-name datasets — totals, tiers, trend states, pillar composites, QC gate verdicts and fair values as published there. Research for information only, not investment advice.*