Same Count, Different Tier 2: Insurers and Energy Rotate In, Deckers Falls Out
Tier 2 held at 25 names in the 13 November edition while its membership rotated: Allstate (68.2 to 70.5, Value pillar 100), EOG (70.8, gate 12 of 13) and Chubb (70.0) crossed in, and Deckers fell out at 68.3 despite the universe's second-highest fundamental composite, 87.3.
Tier 2 ends the 13 November edition (prices of 12 November) with exactly the same headcount it started with — 25 names — and almost nothing else about it is the same. Three names crossed in, three crossed out, breadth across the 515-name universe ran negative (177 scores rose, 291 fell), and the day's most instructive move was an exit: the company with the second-highest fundamental composite in the entire universe lost its Tier 2 seat because the market's half of its score collapsed.
The entrances: value did the lifting
The Allstate Corporation (ALL) made the largest crossing, 68.2 to 70.5. Its fundamental composite is a modest 65.1, but the Value pillar is a perfect 100.0 and the technical score is 83.0 in an UPTREND state — a cheap-and-rising profile. The QC gate dissents (NOT QUALIFIED, 10 of 13), so the crossing arrives with the usual asterisk: the composite admits it, the gate has not confirmed it.
EOG Resources (EOG) edged 69.9 to 70.8, the closest of the entrants to a full endorsement: the QC gate passes 12 of 13 criteria, one short of QUALIFIED, with a fundamental composite of 68.5 and a technical score of 76.3 in an UPTREND. The restraint comes from price, not quality — its external fair value is $150 against a price of $155.62, a margin of safety of about −4%. EOG is a quality crossing at a full price.
Chubb (CB) crossed at exactly 70.0, up from 69.7, on the same insurance pattern as Allstate: a Value pillar of 99.5, a fundamental composite of 67.4, a technical score of 76.0, and a gate that dissents at 9 of 13. Two of the day's three entrants are insurers carried by the value column — the scorecard is saying the market's cheapest quality right now sits in insurance, and the gate is saying it is not yet proven quality.
The exits: three different failures
Deckers Outdoor (DECK) fell 70.7 to 68.3 and out of Tier 2 — while holding a fundamental composite of 87.3, the second-highest in the 515-name universe behind only NVIDIA's 87.6. Its Quality, Value, Shareholder Returns and Health pillars all score between 83 and 100. What failed is the other 30% of the score: the technical reading collapsed to 24.1 and the trend state flipped to DRIFTING, at a price of $84.53. Deckers is the scorecard's two halves in open disagreement — the business graded like the best in the universe, the tape graded like one of the weakest — and the tier line follows the blend, not either half alone.
Williams-Sonoma (WSM), yesterday's entrant, reversed straight back out, 70.0 to 68.7 — a one-day Tier 2 stay that underlines what a borderline crossing on a technical score alone is worth. AppLovin (APP) slipped 70.0 to 69.9, missing the line by a tenth of a point despite a fundamental composite of 79.9; its technical score of 46.7 in a RECOVERING state is the drag.
The top, and the tape underneath
Arista Networks (ANET) extended its lead at #1, 77.0 to 77.8 (fundamental 72.1, technical 91.0, QC QUALIFIED at 11 of 13, external fair value $230 against a $206.63 price — a margin of safety of about +10%). ResMed consolidated yesterday's return at 72.3 with its perfect 13-of-13 gate intact, and DexCom — yesterday's gate-dissenting returnee — improved its gate count from 8 to 9 of 13 while rising to 70.8. The QUALIFIED count across the universe held at 13.
Underneath, the tape narrowed: Tier 3 shrank from 106 names to 101 as five names slipped into Tier 4 (among them U.S. Bancorp, Fifth Third, Nasdaq and Ross Stores, all falling from just above 60 to just below it), and scores fell for 291 of 515 names. A flat Tier 2 count on a down day is rotation, not strength — the tier held its number by swapping its membership.
What it means
A tier is a blend, and blends hide arguments. Tonight's edition contains the full set: a value-led insurer the gate won't confirm (ALL), a quality energy name at a full price (EOG), and a fundamental leader expelled by its own chart (DECK). Reading any one column alone — score, gate, or margin of safety — would have misdescribed all three. The two crossings worth watching next are the ones where the columns are closest to agreeing: EOG, one gate criterion short; and Deckers, whose seat returns the moment the tape stops contradicting the business.
Sources: External 516 KPI Scorecard, edition of 13 November 2026 (prices of 12 November), full 515-name dataset — totals, tiers, trend states, pillar composites, QC gate verdicts and external fair values as published there. Research for information only, not investment advice.